counter stats
Behind The Green Score: How Metacritic Actually Calculates Game And User Ratings

Alright, gather 'round, folks. I've got a tale to spin about the mysterious world of Metacritic, that enigmatic site that decides whether your new game is a smash hit or a flop faster than you can say "Achievement unlocked!".

Once Upon a Time in a Server Farm

Imagine, if you will, a vast server farm, humming like a thousand tiny bees, deep in the heart of the internet. This is where Metacritic's magic happens. Now, I'm no data whisperer, but I've heard tales from those who've ventured into the inner sanctum. And let me tell you, it's not just a bunch of computers sitting there, twiddling their thumbs until a new game drops. No, no, no. They're busy, folks. Busy calculating.

Critic's Corner

First up, let's talk critics. These are the bigwigs, the tastemakers, the ones who get to play games before you do (lucky devils). Metacritic treats their reviews like precious gems, each one carefully weighed and measured. But here's where it gets interesting - they don't just take the score at face value. Oh no, that would be too easy.

Metacritic uses something called a weighted average. It's like when you're ordering pizza with your friends and someone insists on getting pineapple. You don't just count one vote for pineapple, you count it three times because, well, it's that bad. Okay, maybe not that bad, but you get the idea. Metacritic gives more weight to reviews from critics they deem more "reliable".

Now, I'm not saying Metacritic has a secret list of critics they trust more than others (or maybe they do, and they're not telling). But they do look at things like how often a critic reviews games, how many other critics agree with them, and even how many people read their reviews. It's like high school popularity contest, but with more spreadsheets.

User Power

But what about us, the little guys? The ones who actually buy the games and play them? Don't worry, Metacritic hasn't forgotten about us. They've just made it a bit more... complicated.

The only Universal-era Crash Bandicoot games to get a green positiveThe only Universal-era Crash Bandicoot games to get a green positive

You see, Metacritic doesn't just take the average of all user reviews. No, that would be too simple. Instead, they use something called a Bayesian average. It's like a regular average, but with a secret ingredient: a bit of math magic that helps them figure out which users are more likely to give fair reviews. It's like trying to find the one person in your friend group who always orders the right pizza, but with more complex algorithms.

And here's where it gets really interesting (or really annoying, depending on your perspective). Metacritic starts off by giving more weight to critic reviews. But as more user reviews come in, the user reviews start to matter more. It's like the critics are the cool kids at the party, but the users are the ones who actually know how to have a good time.

And Then There Were Scores

So, Metacritic crunches all these numbers, and out pops a score. But here's the thing - that score is always changing. It's like trying to nail jelly to a wall. As more reviews come in, the score shifts and wobbles. It's enough to make your head spin.

The only Universal-era Crash Bandicoot games to get a green positiveThe only Universal-era Crash Bandicoot games to get a green positive

But fear not, dear reader! Because Metacritic has a secret weapon. A failsafe. A... Metascore. It's like the score's older, wiser cousin. It doesn't change as much as the user score, because Metacritic smooths out the wrinkles with their fancy math. It's the score that matters, the one that makes or breaks a game's reputation.

And That's How You Make a Metascore

So there you have it, folks. The not-so-secret formula behind Metacritic's magic. It's a mix of math, mystery, and more math. It's a tale as old as time (or at least as old as the internet), a story of numbers and words and people all coming together to decide whether your new game is a masterpiece or a disaster.

Now, if you'll excuse me, I've got some pineapple pizza to order. And don't worry, I'll make sure to weight my vote appropriately.