counter stats
Can I Use Vegetable Oil Instead Of Shortening

So, I Tried to Make Cookies with Vegetable Oil... Here's What Happened

You know those days when you're craving something sweet, and you decide to bake cookies? Well, I had one of those days recently. But here's the thing, I was all out of shortening. Now, I could have gone to the store, but who wants to put on real pants for that? So, I thought, "Hey, I've got vegetable oil. Can I use that instead?"

I mean, they're both oils, right? How different could they be?

Shortening vs. Vegetable Oil: The Great Debate

Before we dive into my baking adventure, let's talk about the main players here. Shortening is a solid fat at room temperature, made from vegetable oils. It's used in baking because it creates a tender, flaky texture in baked goods. Vegetable oil, on the other hand, is a liquid at room temperature. It's used for cooking and, as I was about to find out, not always for baking.

Pro tip: Always check your recipe. Some recipes can handle oil substitutions, but others are more finicky.

Why Substituting Oil for Shortening Can Go Wrong

When you substitute oil for shortening, you're changing the structure of your baked good. Shortening has a higher melting point, which means it stays solid longer. This helps create flaky layers in pie crusts and keeps cookies from spreading too much. Oil, being a liquid, doesn't do this.

But hey, I was feeling adventurous. I grabbed my oil, measured it out, and started mixing. The dough looked a bit different, but I figured, "What's the worst that could happen?"

Can You Substitute Shortening With Vegetable Oil at Laura McDonald blogCan You Substitute Shortening With Vegetable Oil at Laura McDonald blog

The Great Cookie Experiment

I popped my cookies into the oven, crossed my fingers, and waited. And waited. And waited some more. You know how cookies usually only take about 10-12 minutes to bake? Mine took almost twice as long. When I finally took them out, they were... interesting.

Side note: If you've ever wondered what it's like to bake cookies in a slow-motion video, I can now tell you. It's not as exciting as you'd think.

My Cookies: A Tale of Two Textures

My cookies were dense. Like, really dense. They were also super crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. It was like eating a cookie sandwich, but not in a good way. The flavor was off too. The oil overpowered the other ingredients, giving my cookies a weird, almost greasy taste.

Vegetable Shortening Vs Vegetable Oil | ReviewhoVegetable Shortening Vs Vegetable Oil | Reviewho

Moral of the story: Just because you can substitute one ingredient for another doesn't mean you should. Always consider the role of the ingredient in the recipe.

When to Use Oil in Baking

Now, don't get me wrong. Oil has its place in baking. It's great for keeping cakes moist and adding richness to quick breads. But it's not a one-size-fits-all solution. Some recipes just need that solid fat to work right.

Next time you're out of shortening, check your recipe. If it's a cake or a quick bread, oil might work just fine. But if it's cookies or pie crust, you might want to make a trip to the store. Or, you know, put on real pants.

Disclaimer: I did eat my cookies. I mean, I'd already baked them, so I figured I might as well. But I won't be making that substitution again anytime soon.