What Girl Scout Cookies Are Being Discontinued

Okay, friend, we need to have a serious chat. It’s about something that hits close to the heart—and the stomach. Girl Scout cookie season is upon us, and with it comes the annual gut punch of which flavors are riding off into the sunset.

I know, I know. It feels like just yesterday you were hoarding Thin Mints in the freezer like a tiny, delicious treasure chest. But the Girl Scouts have spoken, and some of our favorites are getting the boot.

Let’s grab a box of tissues (or maybe a sleeve of cookies) and dive in. Here’s the official list of what’s being discontinued in 2025. Grab your wallet and your willpower.

The Big Goodbye: Toast-Yay! Is Toast.

If you’ve never had a Toast-Yay!, you’re not alone—but you’re also missing out. These were the French toast–inspired cookies shaped like little slices of toast, dusted with cinnamon and sugar. They were basically a breakfast you could justify eating at 10 p.m.

Well, adieu, my crunchy breakfast friends. The Girl Scouts announced that Toast-Yay! is being discontinued after its limited run. It was a fun experiment, like when your aunt tries to bake a kale brownie—noble, but not destined for the hall of fame.

If you see a box, grab it. Consider it the cookie equivalent of a final concert tour. They’re going out with a buttery, cinnamon bang.

Also Leaving: S’mores (The OG Version)

This one hurts. The S’mores cookie—the one that mimics a classic campfire treat with graham, chocolate, and marshmallow—is being discontinued. Yes, you read that right. The cookie that tasted like summer camp without the mosquito bites is gone.

Now, there’s a tiny silver lining. These were the original S’mores, not the “S’mores with a different recipe” that some regions sell. So it’s a specific flavor of heartbreak. Think of it like losing your favorite pair of jeans, but the store still sells a similar style—it’s just not the same.

If you have a box stashed in your pantry, hug it. You might even want to light a candle and sing “Kumbaya” as you eat them.

Girl Scout cookies: Two flavors set to be discontinued after 2025

Wait, What About Lemon-Ups?

Ah, the Lemon-Ups. These tangy, lemon-flavored cookies with little inspirational messages printed on them are also getting the ax. You know, the ones that say “Dare to Dream” or “Be a Boss” while you’re munching on your fifth one? Yeah, those are toast (pun intended).

The lemon cookie lineage has always been a bit of a soap opera. First we had Lemon Chalet Cremes. Then Lemonades. Then Lemon-Ups. At this point, I think the Girl Scouts are just messing with us. But this time, it’s for real. Lemon-Ups are out.

Pro tip: If you love lemon, stock up on Thin Mints and pretend they’re lemon by closing your eyes. (Okay, that’s a terrible idea. Just buy the actual boxes while you can.)

The Unofficial Casualty: Girl Scout S’mores (The Other One)

I’ve got to mention this because my inbox is already full of panicked texts. There’s a second S’mores cookie out there, made by a different baker, and it’s also being discontinued. Yes, both S’mores flavors are disappearing like a campfire in the rain.

So if you’re a S’mores stan, you’re in full mourning mode. But hey, this opens the door for exciting new flavors in the future. The Girl Scouts are like the Netflix of cookies—they cancel your favorite show, but then they drop a new season of something weird you end up loving.

Remember when they brought back Thin Mints with caramel? No? That’s because it was a fever dream. But change is the only constant, my friend.

Two Girl Scout Cookies Are Being Discontinued - PureWow

What’s Not Going Anywhere

Before you spiral into despair, let’s celebrate the survivors. Thin Mints are eternal—they’ll outlast cockroaches and batteries. Samoas (a.k.a. Caramel deLites) are still here, dripping with coconut and caramel. Tagalongs (Peanut Butter Patties) are safe, because peanut butter and chocolate is a constitutional right.

Trefoils (the shortbread classics) aren’t going anywhere either. They’re the boring but reliable friend who always shows up. And Do-si-dos (Peanut Butter Sandwich) are still ready to crumble in your coffee. So don’t panic—you haven’t lost everything.

Just pretend the discontinued ones are like that ex you still miss sometimes. It’s okay to move on. There are new cookies to love.

The Uplifting Conclusion: Cookie Karma Is Real

Here’s the thing about Girl Scout cookies being discontinued: it’s actually a good sign. The organization rotates flavors to keep things fresh and to support their mission of teaching girls entrepreneurship. Every time a cookie disappears, it makes room for something new—and sometimes, that new thing is a banger.

Think of it like a butterfly effect. One cookie flutters away, and a whole new flavor flutters in. Maybe next year we’ll get a Matcha Mint or Churro Crunch. Who knows? The possibilities are as endless as your freezer space.

So take a deep breath. Hug your remaining boxes of Toast-Yay! and S’mores. Eat them with joy. And remember: you are stronger than a cookie shortage. You’ve survived the loss of Pizza Hut’s p’zone. You can survive this.

Now go forth, buy a few extra boxes, and share them with a friend. Because in the end, it’s not about the cookie—it’s about the memories you make while eating them. And those, my friend, are never discontinued.