What Did Jacqueline Woodson's Teachers Think Of Her Writing

So, you want to know what Jacqueline Woodson’s teachers really thought of her writing. Spoiler alert: it wasn’t all gold stars and standing ovations. In fact, some of them probably wanted to trade her for a quiet kid who liked math.

The "You’re Doing It Wrong" Phase

Early on, young Jacqueline had a habit of writing poetry that refused to rhyme. This, apparently, was a crime against third-grade grammar. One teacher, Mrs. Something-or-Other, reportedly sighed, “Honey, a poem has to rhyme,” while handing back a paper drenched in red ink.

But Jacqueline, being a stubborn little genius, just shrugged and kept scribbling. She figured that rules were for people who didn’t have better stories to tell. Spoiler: she was right.

The "Too Much Feeling" Problem

Then came middle school, where teachers apparently wanted essays that read like instruction manuals for a toaster. Jacqueline’s writing? It was a flood of emotions, family secrets, and kids who cried at the dinner table. One teacher wrote in the margin, “Dial down the drama, Woodson.”

Imagine getting a note that says, “Your heart is too loud.” That’s basically what happened. But Jacqueline took that critique and turned it into a superpower. She started editing, not dialing down.

The "You’re Not Like the Other Kids" Whisper

Here’s a surprising fact: many of her teachers didn’t just critique her—they didn’t know what to do with her. She was a Black girl from Ohio writing about broken families and segregated schools in the 1960s. That wasn’t on the lesson plan. One teacher allegedly muttered, “This isn’t Little House on the Prairie.”

But here’s the kicker: those same teachers kept passing her along because her stories were weirdly good. They couldn’t fix her prose, so they just hoped she’d grow out of it. She didn’t. She grew into a National Ambassador for Young People’s Literature.

The "This Kid Might Be a Problem" Look

By high school, Jacqueline’s writing had a reputation. One teacher—let’s call him Mr. Boredom—reportedly gave her a C because her essay on “My Summer Vacation” didn’t mention the beach. Instead, she wrote about a cousin who went to jail and a grandma who sang hymns in the kitchen.

A guide to the works of Jacqueline Woodson | Jacqueline woodson

“This is too personal,” Mr. Boredom scrawled. Jacqueline apparently responded (in her head) with, “Too personal? It’s my life.” She got an A in that class anyway because the principal read the essay and cried.

The Secret: They Were All Wrong

Let’s be real: most of her teachers were functioning in a fog of standardized tests. They wanted five-paragraph essays with a thesis statement that could be printed on a t-shirt. Jacqueline handed in pages about a girl whose father left and a dog that died. Total chaos.

But one teacher—a brave soul named Ms. Harper—finally got it. She pulled Jacqueline aside and said, “Your writing is like a train that’s trying to fly. Just keep it on the tracks a little, okay?” That’s the closest any teacher came to saying, “You’re a genius, but you’re also a headache.”

The "You’ll Never Make a Living" Speech

Of course, there was the career counselor. You know the type: a man with a tie that screamed “I gave up.” He looked at Jacqueline’s writing samples and said, “You know, they don’t pay for sad poems about Brooklyn.” Jacqueline smiled, thanked him, and then wrote Brown Girl Dreaming, which won the National Book Award.

That counselor now probably works at a DMV. Do you think he’s still giving bad advice? I hope he is, because it makes a great story.

Experience Jacqueline Woodson's Work on Audio - Penguin Random House Audio

The Unexpected Fan Club

Here’s a twist: not all her teachers were villains. One English teacher, Mrs. Bowers, secretly kept copies of Jacqueline’s stories in her desk drawer. When Woodson won her first big award, Mrs. Bowers wrote her a letter: “I always knew you’d be famous. I just hoped you’d stop using so many commas.”

Jacqueline still uses too many commas. It’s her thing now. It is a feature, not a bug.

The Final Lesson: Teachers Are Just Humans With Red Pens

Here’s the truth: Woodson’s teachers were confused by talent that didn’t fit into a neatly graded box. They wanted neat, tidy sentences. She gave them messy, beautiful truth. They gave her B-minuses and confused frowns.

But Jacqueline Woodson didn’t listen to them. She listened to the voice in her head that said, “Keep writing, even if it makes teachers cry or sigh.” Today, that voice has her name on a MacArthur Genius Grant.

So, what do those old teachers think now? Probably the same thing they always thought: “I have no idea how she did it, but I’m glad I didn’t fail her.” And the best part? Their confusion is now a hilarious anecdote in a coffee shop conversation. You’re welcome.

Now go write something that would terrify your third-grade teacher. It’s the only way to be truly free.