Which Of The Property Brothers Is Gay

The Property Brothers have captivated millions with their renovation magic and sibling chemistry. But one question keeps popping up across forums, dinner tables, and late-night Google searches alike. Which of the Property Brothers is gay? Let's clear the air with warm honesty and a little playful curiosity.

For those living under a beautifully renovated rock, the Property Brothers consist of Drew Scott and Jonathan Scott, twin brothers from Vancouver, Canada. They parlayed their charisma into a full-blown media empire featuring TV shows, books, podcasts, and a lifestyle brand.

Meet the Brothers Behind the Hard Hats

Drew is the slightly shorter twin with a contagious smile and a knack for host-first energy. Jonathan, the taller one, brings a design-forward eye and a deep voice that could narrate a documentary about anything.

Together, they've helped thousands of homeowners fall in love with their living spaces. Their shows like Property Brothers, Drew & Jonathan Scott, and Buying and Selling prove that family and business can mix when the foundation is strong.

So, the Big Question: Is Either Brother Gay?

Here's the straightforward answer: neither Drew nor Jonathan Scott has publicly identified as gay. As of now, both brothers are openly in heterosexual relationships and have never disclosed otherwise.

Drew has been happily married to Linda Phan since 2018, and the couple shares an adorable family life full of laughter and DIY chatter. Jonathan was most notably linked to Caitlin McCalla and later to Australian wrestler Caitlin McCalla—though his most public romance was with Jacinta Barretto.

It's worth mentioning that Jonathan's ex-girlfriend, Jacinta Barretto, went on to publicly come out as a member of the LGBTQ+ community. Her journey inspired a lot of fan discussion about sexuality and identity.

Why Does This Question Pop Up So Often?

The internet loves a mystery, and celebrity twin brothers with earnest smiles make for easy speculation. Pop culture has a long history of guessing romantic identities based on mannerisms or fashion choices.

The twin 'Property Brothers' are stars of HGTV

Think about how frequently fans project narratives onto figures like Stephen Colbert or Craig Nelson just because of a joke or a wardrobe choice. It's a reminder that public curiosity about celebrity sexuality is nothing new.

However, casually speculating about someone's orientation can reinforce the idea that people owe the public an explanation for who they love. Respecting someone's privacy, even when curiosity runs high, is always the classiest move.

A Quick Glossary for the Conversation

Let's keep a few key terms handy: gay refers to a person attracted to the same gender, while straight refers to attraction to a different gender. Identity is personal and not always binary, so reminding ourselves that nuance exists is a wonderful habit.

Representation matters, whether it shows up on reality TV or at your neighborhood block party. Celebrating publicly gay figures—like RuPaul, Iggy Pop fans' favorite pop artists, or Harvey Fierstein—keeps visibility alive in mainstream spaces.

What the Evidence Actually Shows

Everything on the public record points to both Grant brothers—sorry, Scott brothers—identifying as straight. Their social media, interviews, and joint ventures reinforce this conclusion without ambiguity.

Prime Video: Property Brothers - Season 9

Jonathan has spoken openly about wanting to start a family with Caitlin McCalla, and Drew's marriage timeline is well documented. Public records and personal narratives align neatly.

If a notable pivot ever happens, they'll likely own it with the same honesty they bring to every reveal on screen. For now, both brothers walk proudly in the identities they've shared with the world.

Practical Tips for Discussing Celebrity Personal Lives

Next time this topic comes up at brunch, try asking why the question interests you rather than jumping to conclusions. Curiosity paired with kindness creates space for real conversation.

Follow responsible media sources and avoid sharing unverified gossip. A good filter for misinformation is asking: "Did the person confirm this themselves?"

And if you truly enjoy the brothers' content, focus on their phenomenal design tips instead of their dating lives. Their advice on staging a home can genuinely change your weekends.

'Property Brothers' Drew and Jonathan Scott Sign New HGTV Deal - Variety

A Few Fun Facts to Impress Your Friends at Dinner

Fun fact: Both brothers were born on April 28, 1978, making them classic April Aries with a stubborn streak. They also grew up around their parents' renovation business, which sparked the entire career.

Another gem: They competed against each other on Family Feud Canada, proving sibling rivalry never really goes away. And Jonathan once shared that he built his first treehouse at age 7—so their design chops started incredibly early.

The Takeaway

Neither Property Brother has come out as gay, and that is where the factual story currently rests. Speculation, while entertaining, should never overshadow a person's right to define their own identity on their own terms.

The brothers remind us that authenticity—whether in interior design or personal life—is always the most attractive quality in a room. Let's carry that spirit into how we talk about real people behind the camera.

In everyday life, choosing curiosity without judgment makes conversations richer and relationships deeper. The next time you wonder about someone's personal life, pause and remember: their story is theirs to tell—and ours to simply enjoy from the sidelines.