Summer I Turned Pretty Similar Shows

Okay, so you finished The Summer I Turned Pretty and now you're sitting there in total denial. You know the feeling — you're scrolling through Netflix, Hulu, or any streaming platform, desperately looking for that next show that hits the same emotional gut punch as Belly's love life.

I've been there. More times than I'd like to admit. So grab your iced coffee, settle in, and let's talk about shows that scratch that exact same itch.

First Up: Why Are We Even Obsessed?

Let's break it down for a second. The Summer I Turned Pretty gives us beach vibes, teenage angst, and a love triangle that genuinely stresses us out. Who didn't form a strong opinion about Team Conrad or Team Jeremiah?

It's the perfect mix of romance, coming-of-age drama, and settings so gorgeous you can practically smell the salt air. That's a tough formula to replicate, but these shows come surprisingly close.

All the Wrong Fives — Yes, Really

If you love the whole "small town, big feelings" energy, this one's for you. It follows three teenagers pretending to be someone they're not, and things get hilariously messy. There's romance, awkward first kisses, and friendship drama that feels dangerously real.

The best part? It has that same breezy, summer-romance energy without taking itself too seriously. You'll laugh, you'll cringe, you'll probably fall asleep watching it at 2 AM. No judgment.

The Kissing Booth Series

Okay, controversial pick here. Some people hate it. But hear me out — if what you want is beach-side romance wrapped in a ride-or-die friendship story, it delivers. The lead characters have that same chemistry that keeps you screaming at your screen.

10 Best TV Shows Like 'The Summer I Turned Pretty' to Watch Now - Just

It's over the top? Absolutely. Is it a little ridiculous? Sure. But isn't that exactly what makes it fun? Sometimes you just need pure, unfiltered popcorn entertainment.

To All the Boys I've Loved Before

Now, you probably already know this one. Of course you do. But it deserves a spot on this list because it captures that same butterflies-in-your-stomach feeling that makes TSITP so addictive.

Lara Jean's love letters are iconic, and Peter Kavinsky still lives rent-free in a lot of people's minds. The vibe is similar: youthful romance, messy emotions, and humor sprinkled all over the place.

Outer Banks

Stick with me on this one. I know it was crime-heavy compared to a sweet summer romance. But the friendship dynamics, the coastal setting, and the constant "who's dating who" drama? It absolutely hits similar notes.

15 Shows To Watch If You Liked The Summer I Turned Pretty

The kids in Outer Banks fight, kiss, and chaos-ise their way through every episode. It's basically TSITP on anxiety-fueled espresso — same elements, higher stakes.

The Summer I Turned Pretty: Season Two and Beyond

Wait — did you rewatch all the seasons already? Because honestly, sometimes the best "similar show" is just going back to the original. Season 2 hit differently, didn't it? The beach scenes alone could fill an entire mental health diary.

The writing keeps evolving with each new season, and the characters grow in ways that make rewatching genuinely rewarding. Sometimes you scratch for alternatives when what you really need is to appreciate what you already have.

Summer Sadness and the Perfect Watchlist

Here's the truth: no show will ever be exactly like The Summer I Turned Pretty. That's fine! That's actually okay. The beauty is in finding shows that carry a similar feeling rather than a literal copy.

Shows Like The Summer I Turned Pretty On Prime | Naked Grapefruit

Beach scenes, love triangles, heartbreak, friendship, and that lingering ache when a season finale rolls around. That's the recipe we're chasing — and these shows bake plenty of it into every episode.

Okay, Your Turn. What's Your Pick?

So there you have it — a listicle disguised as a coffee chat with zero real structure. You're welcome. Now the real question is: what did I'm missing?

Drop your own recommendations. I'm genuinely curious which show gave you the same belly-contraction emotional experience that TSITP did. Because trust me — we're all looking for the next one.

Now go queue up something good. And remember: team whoever gives their protagonist one single moment of peace. They've deserved it.